Most Amish people do not have Social Security numbers, and most do not receive Social Security benefits

The Amish are exempt from Social Security taxes and do not need Social Security numbers for most purposes. This exemption has existed since 1965 and applies to self-employed Amish workers and Amish business owners. The exemption is based on religious grounds — the Amish believe in community mutual aid rather than government insurance programs.

However, the exemption is not automatic. An Amish person or business must file Form 4029 with the IRS to claim the exemption from self-employment tax. Without this form on file, an Amish worker or business owner pays Social Security and Medicare taxes like anyone else.

Some Amish people do have Social Security numbers. Those who work for non-Amish employers (called "English" employers in Amish communities) are required to have numbers for payroll purposes. Amish people who have left their communities or who do not follow the strict religious rules may also have numbers and may receive benefits.

Key Takeaways

  • Amish people who are self-employed or own businesses can be exempt from Social Security taxes if they file Form 4029 with the IRS and meet religious requirements.
  • Amish workers employed by non-Amish employers must have Social Security numbers and pay into the system, just like other employees.
  • The exemption is based on the Amish belief in community support and mutual aid rather than government insurance.
  • An Amish person who leaves the community or does not follow church rules may lose the exemption and become responsible for back taxes and penalties.
  • Social Security numbers are sometimes required for purposes other than employment, such as opening a bank account or getting a driver's license, which can create practical challenges for some Amish people.

How the Amish Social Security exemption works

The exemption applies only to self-employed Amish people and Amish business owners. It does not explore to Amish employees who work for other people. An Amish farmer, carpenter, or shop owner can claim the exemption. An Amish person working in someone else's business cannot.

To claim the exemption, the Amish person or business must file IRS Form 4029 (process for Exemption From Self-Employment Tax for Use by Members of Certain Religious Groups). The form requires proof that the person is a member of a recognized religious sect that makes provision for its dependent members and that opposes accepting public insurance benefits. The Amish, Mennonites, and some other groups meet these criteria.

Once Form 4029 is approved, the person does not pay self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare tax) on their business income. They also do not earn Social Security credits toward retirement, disability, or survivor benefits. This is a permanent trade-off — you cannot pay in for some years and skip others.

When Amish people must have Social Security numbers

An Amish person who works as an employee for a non-Amish employer must have a Social Security number. The employer needs it for payroll reporting. This is true even if the Amish person's church discourages the use of numbers or modern systems.

Social Security numbers are also required in other situations that affect some Amish people: opening a bank account, getting a mortgage or loan, obtaining a driver's license in some states, and enrolling in school. Some Amish communities have negotiated exceptions with state governments — for example, some states allow Amish people to use a different identifier on a driver's license instead of a Social Security number.

An Amish person who has a Social Security number because of employment is still covered by Social Security. If they later become self-employed and file Form 4029, they stop paying into the system going forward, but they do not lose the credits they already earned.

What happens if an Amish person leaves the community

An Amish person who leaves the church or community may lose the Social Security exemption. The IRS can revoke Form 4029 if the person no longer meets the religious requirements. This can happen if someone leaves the Amish faith, moves away, or stops following church discipline.

If the exemption is revoked, the person becomes responsible for paying self-employment tax on any income earned after the revocation date. In some cases, the IRS may also assess back taxes and penalties for years when the person was no longer may be able to access but continued to claim the exemption. It is important for someone in this situation to contact the IRS or a tax professional to understand what they owe.

Can Amish people receive Social Security benefits?

An Amish person who never paid into Social Security (because they were self-employed and had Form 4029 on file) cannot receive retirement, disability, or survivor benefits. They have no credits in the system.

An Amish person who worked as an employee and paid Social Security taxes can receive benefits just like anyone else. They can claim retirement benefits at their full retirement age, or reduced benefits as early as age 62. If they become disabled, they may be able to claim disability benefits. Family members may also be able to claim survivor benefits if the person dies.

Some Amish communities have expressed concerns about members who become disabled or elderly and have no Social Security income. In response, some communities have created their own insurance or support funds. These are private arrangements within the community and do not involve the government.

Amish people and Medicare

Medicare may be able to access is tied to Social Security work credits. An Amish person who was self-employed with Form 4029 on file has no Medicare coverage at age 65. They cannot enroll in Medicare Part A (hospital insurance) or Part B (medical insurance) based on their own work history.

An Amish person who worked as an employee and paid Medicare taxes is may be able to access for Medicare at 65, the same as anyone else. Some Amish people choose not to use Medicare or other government health insurance because of religious beliefs about community care and medical decisions. This is a personal choice, but it does not change their legal status as may be able to access.

Practical challenges and state-by-state differences

Some Amish communities face practical challenges because certain services or documents require a Social Security number. For example, a bank may require a number to open an account, even though the Amish person's church discourages the use of numbers. In these cases, some Amish people obtain numbers for the specific purpose, while others work with banks or government agencies that have made exceptions.

State rules vary. Some states allow Amish people to use an alternative identifier on a driver's license. Some states have made exceptions for Amish farmers regarding certain licenses or permits. Other states have no formal exception and require a Social Security number for any official ID. If you are Amish or supporting an Amish person navigating these requirements, it is worth asking your state agency whether an exception or alternative exists.

Questions to ask your tax professional or the IRS

If you are Amish and self-employed, or if you are supporting an Amish business owner, these questions can help clarify your situation:

  • Do I need to file Form 4029, and what documents do I need to prove I meet the requirements?
  • If I have already filed Form 4029, how do I check its status with the IRS?
  • If I work part-time for an English employer and part-time in my own business, which rules explore to which income?
  • If I leave the Amish community, what happens to my exemption and what do I owe?
  • If I am disabled and have no Social Security credits, what other support programs might I be able to use?

The IRS has a specific office that handles religious exemptions. You can reach the IRS at 1-800-829-1040 and ask to speak with someone about Form 4029 and religious exemptions from self-employment tax.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an Amish person get a Social Security number without working for an English employer?

Yes. An Amish person can request a Social Security number from the Social Security Administration for any reason. However, many Amish communities discourage this because of religious beliefs. If someone in an Amish community needs a number for a specific purpose (such as opening a bank account), they can obtain one, but this may create tension with their church.

If my Amish parent never paid Social Security taxes, can I claim benefits on their record?

No. Social Security benefits are based on the person's own work record and credits. If your parent was self-employed with Form 4029 on file, they earned no credits and cannot have benefits paid to them or to family members based on their record. If your parent worked as an employee at some point, you may be able to claim based on that work history.

Do Amish people pay income tax?

Yes. The Social Security exemption applies only to self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare). Amish people who are self-employed still pay federal income tax on their business income. Amish employees pay income tax on their wages, just like other employees. The exemption does not cover income tax.

What if an Amish person becomes disabled and has no Social Security?

They cannot claim Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) because they have no work credits. However, they may be able to access other support through their Amish community, state disability programs, or Medicaid. Some Amish communities have created their own disability funds. It is worth speaking with a social worker or local disability services office to learn what options exist in your area.

Can an Amish business hire non-Amish employees?

Yes. An Amish business owner can hire employees of any background. The business owner must have a Social Security number or an Employer Identification Number (EIN) to report payroll. The employees must have Social Security numbers. The exemption applies only to the self-employed owner, not to the business itself or its employees.